Changing information tests your ability to update a decision, not to defend your first guess.
A briefing exercise can appear to reward quick answers. It actually exposes whether you can sort information, make a proportionate decision and communicate it clearly. Treat an original fictional scenario as practice in reasoning, never as a leaked or guaranteed replica of an assessment.
Start with a real attempt: Separate facts from assumptions. Give a short recommendation, explain the trade-off and name what you would check before acting.
Need the full recruitment sequence as well? See the police constable selection pathway. Its official-source comparison will help you check that you are practising for the right stage.